Sunday, February 13, 2011

'An Apple A Day Keeps The Doctor Away ' , Is There A Prescription To Keep An Octegenarion Doctor Away from Malaysian politics For Good?

Click to show "Nelson Mandela" result 5 

Have you ever experienced that brain tingling sensation  as you lower yourself, as if into water and become gradually immersed in a subject that is so engaging that you wish to savor again and again the feel of the water lapping over you and caressing you. This is my rather humble attempt to describe reading  what had been written of worldly figures  the likes of  Ghandi , Mandela  and/or  Martin Luther King  , just to name a few. 

Mohandas Mahatma Gandhi - 018

These great men  who through their  magnificent struggle for equality and a just society   have received  a multitude of citations by numerous respectable leaders the world over for their ultimate sacrificed  - "been of very great benefit to humanity"

Click to show "Mahathir bin Mohamad" result 14
Grateful thanks must go to Incurable logophilia for drawing me to read Tom Plate’s new book “Doctor M: Operation Malaysia – Conversations with Mahathir Mohamad
Almost every page of  the book as it had drawn myself   will undoubtedly  draw readers  in to reflect upon situations and relationships in the context of  Malaysia  of the 1980's. and 90s. The' Doctor' brings into close juxtaposition the emotional and political climate as his version of  "ops lalang " unfolds. 

 This leaves me with one lingering question , as to not drag his 'conversations' any further. What has becomed  of the good doctor? 

If only he could recite this poem in his twilight years

The Coming of Wisdom with Time:

“Though leaves are many, the root is one;
Through all the lying days of my youth
I swayed my leaves and flowers in the sun
Now I may wither into the truth”

Finally, the power of this work lay for me in the descriptions of place, a way of living, the sadness of lives that were so inexorably intertwined with conventions of the time and place. 
My writeup  is littered with multi colouredstickies’ highlighting yet another passage worthy of comment and reflection. My remaining lingering thought is , like the Interlok Novel , that this is a work of fiction yet like the Interlok Novel , lives were lived in this book and man’s inhumanity to man and his inability to respect his fellow human continue to this day – wherever we are. What is our response to the injustices around and within us today?

I leave you readers to reflect upon the comments of one of the casualties of  Operasi Lalang :


Lim Kit Siang profile picture


Would Opposition leaders have let off Mahathir for two decades if he had broken his assurance before Operation Lalang that they would not be arrested under the ISA?

Former Prime Minister Tun Dr. Mahathir Mohamad has maintained what he said in Tom Plate’s new book “Doctor M: Operation Malaysia – Conversations with Mahathir Mohamad” that he had “actually met all of the opposition members (beforehand) and assured them that they would not be arrested”.
Following my rebuttal that I had never met Mahathir and that he never gave me any assurance that I would not be arrested before the launch of Operation Lalang on Oct. 27, 1987, Mahathir repeated yesterday: “I met Kit Siang and his friends as a group”.
He said he felt some of the political figures did not need to serve detention at that time.
“It was the police who took action against them and I accepted their decision.”
I had challenged Mahathir to name the Opposition leaders he had met and given assurance that they would not be arrested – now reduced to “Kit Siang and his friends as a group” –but subsequently overruled by the police in the Operation Lalang crackdown, but Mahathir has not been able to name anyone of the others.

The simplest rebuttal to Mahathir’s claim would be to pose the question – Whether the Opposition leaders to whom Mahathir had given an assurance that they would not be arrested in an Internal Security Act (ISA) crackdown would have let off Mahathir for two decades if he had broken his solemn word to us before Operation Lalang of no ISA arrests?
We would have ridiculed him as a impotent Prime Minister and Home Minister at the beck-and-call of the Police – which everybody know was not true.
Former Inspector-General of Police Tun Hanif Omar has come out to corroborate Mahathir’s version of Operation Lalang, claiming that “it was entirely the police’s decision”.
If so, can Hanif explain why the UMNO Youth leader at the time, Datuk Seri Najib Razak, was not arrested in the Operation Lalang crackdown as it was the Umno and Umno Youth leaders who were chiefly responsible for creating the racial tensions of October 1987?
Or was Najib in the police arrest list but overruled by Mahathir?
I did pose this question to Mahathir after my release together with Guan Eng from Kamunting Detention Centre on April 19, 1989 – the last two Operation Lalang detainees to be set free after 18 months of detention.
Both of us were released without conditions but there were 16 former Operation Lalang detainees who were subject to restrictive conditions relating to freedom of speech and movement depriving them of their civic and political rights.
In my meeting with Mahathir on 6th May 1989, I had asked Mahathir point-blank why Najib had not been detained if Operation Lalang was allegedly to deal with the racial tensions in October 1987, referring in particular to the Umno Youth rally at Jalan Raja Muda Stadium in Kuala Lumpur on 17th October 1987 with banners displaying slogans: “MAY 13 HAS BEGUN” and “SOAK IT (KRIS) WITH CHINESE BLOOD”.
There was no proper answer from Mahathir, only the typical illogical Mahathir retort: “Who asked you to provoke him?”
Mahathir never told me that it was the Police who wanted to make the Operation Lalang arrests and that he had no choice as Home Minister but to go along.
Despite Hanif’s collaboration, nobody would believe that Mahathir was not the mastermind of the Operation Lalang arrests to consolidate his power position in Umno.
It is public knowledge at the time that Hanif was on his way out, and the man who had the full confidence of the Prime Minister was the then Special Branch Director, Tan Sri Rahim Noor, whom everybody expected to take over as IGP after Hanif. May be, an explanation from Rahim Noor might be more appropriate than from Hanif.
Be that as it may, what is intriguing is why Mahathir is trying to rewrite history as to who was responsible for the Operation Lalang arrests – some two decades after the darkest chapter of human rights in Malaysia.
This is not the first time that Mahahtir had passed the buck of responsibility for Operation Lalang to the police. He did it the first time in August 2006 and I had immediately rebutted him at the time

Parti Warisan Sabah janganlah Sampai dilabel ' Ibarat Melukut Di Tepi Gantang '

"Berputar pada sentimen kenegerian seperti yang hangat digempar gemburkan pucuk pimpinan parti secara idealnya dilepaskan pada ...